Navigation
Suscribe
Menu Search Facebook Twitter
Search Close
Menu ALL SECTIONS
  • Capital Coahuila
  • Capital Hidalgo
  • Capital Jalisco
  • Capital Morelos
  • Capital Oaxaca
  • Capital Puebla
  • Capital Quintana Roo
  • Capital Querétaro
  • Capital Veracruz
  • Capital México
  • Capital Michoacán
  • Capital Mujer
  • Reporte Índigo
  • Estadio Deportes
  • The News
  • Efekto
  • Diario DF
  • Capital Edo. de Méx.
  • Green TV
  • Revista Cambio
Radio Capital
Pirata FM
Capital Máxima
Capital FM
Digital
Prensa
Radio
TV
X
Newsletter
Facebook Twitter
X Welcome! Subscribe to our newsletter and receive news, data, statistical and exclusive promotions for subscribers
World

Australia's Top Court Hears Bid to Stop Gay Marriage Survey

Same-sex marriage advocates are arguing in the High Court that the government does not have the constitutional power to start the postal survey next week

Men with rainbow flags stand in front of the Brandenburg Gate at an event organized by the SPD to celebrate the legalization of same-sex marriage in Berlin, Germany, photo: AP/Michael Kappeler/dpa
2 weeks ago

CANBERRA – Gay rights advocates went to Australia’s highest court on Tuesday in a bid to prevent the government from surveying the public on whether gay marriage should be legalized.

The advocates want the Parliament to decide the issue without consultation with the public and are arguing in the High Court that the government does not have the constitutional power to start the postal survey next week.

Opinion polls show that most Australians want same-sex marriage legalized, but many advocates question how representative of Australian attitudes the postal survey would be.

The seven judges will hear two similar cases simultaneously over Tuesday and Wednesday in the city of Melbourne. The judges could rule on the validity of the survey as early as Wednesday and prevent ballots being posted to voters from Sept. 12.


One case is brought by independent lawmaker Andrew Wilkie and gay rights campaigners Felicity Marlowe and Shelley Argent.

Argent has described the survey as a “demeaning, hate-filled and pointless vote that will go nowhere and resolve nothing.”

The second case is brought by Janet Rice, a senator in the minor Greens party who is married to a transgender partner with a male birth certificate, and the Australian Marriage Equality lobby group.

The survey is the second choice of Prime Minister Malcolm Turnbull’s conservative government that had promised a rare, compulsory vote known as a plebiscite.

But the Senate refused to approve the 170 million Australian dollars ($135 million) that that vote on Nov. 25 would have cost.

So the government is pushing for a unique, voluntary postal vote without Senate approval at a cost of AU$122 million.

If a majority want marriage equality, Parliament would be allowed to decide the issue by December. But some lawmakers have said their votes in Parliament would not be swayed by public opinion, raising questions about why the public is being surveyed.


Wilkie’s case is that the government’s power to fund the vote without Senate approval can only be used in unforeseen emergencies and not in the ordinary business of government.

Even if the government could fund the vote, Wilkie argues that it could not make the Australian Bureau of Statistics carry it out.

While the bureau has the power to obtain statistical data from the Australian population, gathering opinions was different, he argues.


Despite the legal cloud hanging over the postal survey, acrimonious campaigns on both sides of the argument are gathering pace.

Turnbull and opposition leader Bill Shorten support gay marriage. But Turnbull’s predecessor and intra-party rival Tony Abbott is a vocal opponent.

Abbott has described a vote against gay marriage as a vote against political correctness.

Many yes-vote supporters including Rice, the litigant, argue that marriage equality is, as the U.S. Supreme Court found, a human right that should not be subjected to an opinion poll.

ROD McGUIRK

Comments Whatsapp Twitter Facebook Share
More From The News
World

Facebook to Release Russia Ads, Beef Up ...

7 hours ago
World

World Powers Rally to Defend Value of Ir ...

8 hours ago
World

Maria Destroys Homes, Triggers Flooding ...

8 hours ago
Mexico

Mexico Shocked By News: Girl Trapped in ...

8 hours ago
Most Popular

Mexico Shocked By News: Girl Trapped in ...

By The Associated Press
Mexico

Earthquake Death Toll Rises to 273

By Notimex
Mexico

7.1 Magnitude Quake Kills 139 as Buildui ...

By The Associated Press
Mexico

Semar: No Missing Child in Collapsed Sch ...

By The Associated Press
Mexico

Relief Centers in Mexico City

By The News
Mexico