The event was an unprecedented gathering of leaders of the Federal Reserve — past and present — to discuss what it feels like to hold what is considered the world's most powerful economic policy-making job
Moderator Fareed Zakaria (L) listens as Federal Reserve chair Janet Yellen (2-L) speaks while seated beside former Federal Reserve chairs Ben Bernanke (2-R), and Paul Volcker (R) during a forum, Thursday, April 7, 2016, in New York. Photo: AP/Kathy Willens, Pool, photo: AP/Kathy Willens, Pool
08 of April 2016 10:19:35
WASHINGTON — Janet Yellen was put on the spot about whether she made a mistake in raising interest rates in December. Ben Bernanke was quizzed about what it felt like to be called a traitor by the governor of Texas.Alan Greenspan was asked if he purposely sought to confuse Congress with his answers. And Paul Volcker was queried about being hung in effigy after he pushed interest rates to levels not seen since the Civil War.The event was an unprecedented gathering of leaders of the Federal Reserve — past and present — to discuss what it feels like to hold what is considered the world's most powerful economic policy-making job.The four Fed leaders appeared Thursday evening at an event to launch a speaker's program honoring Volcker at the International House in New York, a residential dormitory for foreign students. Greenspan appeared by video link from Washington.Together, the tenures of the four participants cover more than one-third of the Fed's 102-year history. Their leadership included the double-digit inflation of the 1970s, the global banking and financial market crises of the 1980s and 1990s and, beginning nearly a decade ago, the worst financial crisis and recession since the Great Depression.Fareed Zakaria of CNN, who moderated the discussion, asked how the four felt in a job with "so much concentrated power" that opened them up to criticism when the economy was not doing well.[caption id="attachment_11887" align="alignleft" width="300"] Former Federal Reserve chair Alan Greenspan appears via video conference to join current Fed Chair Janet Yellen and former Fed chairs Ben Bernanke and Paul Volcker during a forum, Thursday, April 7, 2016, in New York. Photo: AP/Kathy Willens, Pool[/caption]Greenspan, who was often accused of trying to dodge tough questions at congressional hearings with big words and incredibly long sentences, did not deny employing that tactic. But he said, "The real problem is that monetary policy is very largely economic forecasting and our ability to forecast is significantly limited and we have to keep the context of what we say in the context of what we know."Bernanke said he didn't like it in 2011 when he was called a traitor by Rick Perry, who was then governor of Texas and a Republican presidential candidate. But he said he realized that criticism came with the job, especially in times when the Fed was trying to pull the country out of the worst recession since the 1930s."We had tremendous responsibilities to address these terrible risks," Bernanke said. "I didn't take the job for adulation."Volcker's policy of high interest rates contributed to pushing the country into two recessions in the early 1980s. But he said even with unhappy farmers and home builders attacking the central bank's policies, the Fed could not have done what it did without broad support from the public for the central bank's attempts to deal with a prolonged bout stagflation, a toxic combination of high inflation and weak economic growth."People were unhappy with malaise and inflation going up," Volcker said. "They felt we were doing something."Yellen, who succeeded Bernanke in February 2014, was quizzed about whether she felt the Fed's rate hike in December, a quarter-point move, had been a mistake. In January, the global economy slowed and financial markets went into a tailspin triggered by rising oil prices and increased weakness in China."I certainly don't regard it as a mistake," Yellen said. She said despite the global weakness, the U.S. economy remains on a solid course. She also disputed the suggestion that the Fed's low rates could be fueling a bubble economy."This is an economy on a solid course, not a bubble economy," she said, during the hour-long program.Yellen said that in December the Fed indicated that the pace of future rate hikes would be gradual and she said that remained the Fed's expectation. The central bank's quarter-point move in December was the first rate hike after seven years in which the benchmark rate was kept at a record low near zero. Many private economists believe the next hike will not occur until June."We think that a gradual pace of rate increases will be appropriate," Yellen said. "The prospects for continued growth and progress in the labor market look good."[caption id="attachment_11888" align="alignright" width="300"] Former Federal Reserve chair Paul Volcker shields his eyes as he scans the audience, Thursday, April 7, 2016, in New York while appearing with current Federal Reserve chairperson Janet Yellen, and former Fed chair Ben Bernanke, as well as Alan Greenspan, by video conference. Photo: AP/Kathy Willens, Pool[/caption]The other Fed officials supported Yellen's view about the economy's prospects with Bernanke saying he did not think there were heightened dangers the country will topple into a recession."The domestic U.S. economy is moving forward, households are pretty strong financially speaking. The housing sector is continuing to expand," Bernanke said. "So I don't see any particular reason to think that a recession is any more likely in 2016 than it was in 2015 or 2014."Private economists viewed Yellen's comments as further support for their view that the Fed, which left its key policy rate unchanged in January and March, will not hike rates at the next meeting in April. They said they still expected just two rate hikes this year in June and December.Sal Guatieri, senior economist at BMO Capital Markets, said while Yellen sounded a bit more upbeat about the economy in her panel appearance "she reaffirmed that some lingering slack in the labor market, global and financial risks and the limited scope for easing to address adverse shocks warrants a cautious approach to normalizing rates."All the Fed leaders stressed that they had not acted alone but with the support of a large group of policymakers and a talented Fed staff, but Volcker said that didn't mean there were not times that they worried about their decisions."I did worry. I worried all the time," Volcker said.He said he sometimes paced so much in his office that he worried about wearing a hole in the rug.